Geek Proud, GeekOut.

Hearthstone – Balance

One of the major draws of a good card game is the balance of the card game. This article will come off as sour grapes, but damn it there is an obvious balance issue going on here! Within balance, there are several really important aspects to pay attention to. You have to be fair to new players by giving them a deck that doesn’t necessarily reward them for having just common and uncommon cards, but at least gives them a relatively fair footing.

With this in mind, I recently started to play Hearthstone again, a brilliant card game by Blizzard Entertainment. My problem is however, it had been several months since I had last truly picked the game up and I felt as if I had been left eating dust that has been collected up behind all of these monstrous new cards around the place. I even had a 9 match losing streak.


A friend of mine introduced me to the newest cards, these Mech cards which were incredibly powerful. They had an ability called Spare Parts on some of them, which gave different effects dependent on the card. But the thing that infuriated me is that it felt, perhaps wrongly, that some of the core mechanics had been changed (even if it was just slightly.)

I play Hearthstone as a Shaman and in the past, I used to be alright at it. I used to get as far as Rank 10-12 with relative ease. This time however, I picked up and turn 2 comes around – the Hunter in front of me uses The Coin, a well known card which is given for free to the second player… and on turn 2, he summons a Random animal which happens to be a 4/4 with taunt.


On turn 1, he summoned one of these dreaded Spare Parts. For 1 mana, he had a 2/1 (not so unfair) but then he also gained one of these Spare Parts cards when that minion died. The Spare Part he received was a card that, again for 1 mana, allowed him to return a minion to his hand. But how is that fair? How something like that happen so easily… and normally?

This isn’t to say there aren’t immensely overpowered cards in Magic: the Gathering, either. I know there are ridiculously overpowered cards but the official tournaments set up by Wizards of the Coast at least bans those cards from competitive play. One of the problems Hearthstone has for me is that, so long as you have the card, you can play it.

So for 3 mana, you get a 4/4 with taunt, but it obviously isn’t a guaranteed taunt 4/4. Yes, it required use of The Coin, but by Turn 2 the Hunter had a 4/4 with taunt on the table! This means that I had to kill that thing off to get over to the Hunter (with my monsters at least), or I had to incapacitate it in some way. As a shaman, this wouldn’t be such an issue, if I weren’t limited to just 2 Hexes. Hex in hearthstone turns a target into a 0/2 Frog with taunt. Needless to say, I didn’t have anything like this and the creature I used to hurt it got killed, before it just got re-healed or he used the Spare Parts he received to just return it to his hand and replay it (which he did later). He played the game perfectly fairly… But the game felt broken to me.


By turn 5, he had almost killed me due to effects like this. He used these Spare Parts to his advantage (which is perfectly fine), but there was nothing I could do in the process. I’ve never been lucky enough to get any legendaries, let alone any epics for my Shaman. It’s made me think… Perhaps it is time to hang up the boots of the Shaman and just play as a Warrior or a Rogue. Heck, when I switched over to my Rogue, who I haven’t even gotten any special cards for, I had 3 wins with her.

Perhaps this is World of Warcraft vanilla syndrome: Where all of the other classes gets powerful and the Shamans get left behind. I hope this is not the case, but if you pick up Hearthstone and you’ve not played for a while, I implore you to fight casual fights for a while until you can get enough gold and enough booster packs. It seems like you might need to play this game regularly to maintain any sort of skill.

Hearthstone TrophyOh but nevermind… Blizzard said there were connection problems for European players last week, which was when I played… So they’ve given us European players two free boosters. Perhaps my luck will change!? Thanks to Blizzard for addressing situations professionally by looking after their players. It also helps keep us players in, hook, line and sinker!

Do you agree with what I’ve noticed about the balance of the game? Do you think I was just incredibly unlucky and that I should just keep going? I’m going to keep going with it regardless, but I was staggered with how suddenly weak and vulnerable my deck suddenly felt. I had to change some things in it immediately and even then it wasn’t perfect.

As always though, comments below, over on Facebook or Twitter and let me know what you think about Hearthstone. Do you like the new Mech cards? Do you think they could be more balanced or is the balance just right?


10 responses

  1. I think there’s an element of luck into it. That hunter card is a core card, by that I mean it’s been there from the start of HS. If your opponent gets Misha out, then it’s bound to be painful. I usually keep my Druid’s 3+ damage spells handy for those cases.

    Spare parts are odd. They’re all useful but only 2 of them are truly powerful: return a minion to your hand and freeze minion. the taunt, +1 attack & +1 defense are handy but not as powerful.

    Right now, with the blackrock adventure you get new synergy effects with dragons IN YOUR HAND, so you have minions buffing if you have a dragon in your hand. It can get quite difficult when just having a single card on your hand can buff a minion to hell and back.

    There is some element of balance tuning, and Blizzard is usually very on top of these things, but until they change something we can only improve our decks, our strategies and try to deal with these new mechanics. Silencing is now perhaps more helpful than ever. It’s why the 4mana Keeper of the Grove is always in my decks.


    May 13, 2015 at 12:57 pm

    • Absolutely. The goal of this article wasnt to dispute Blizzard as a company as I even mentioned their nice gesture. Instead, as you say, they need to fine tune the balance.

      Time will tell what they do. Amazing reply Kev :)

      Liked by 1 person

      May 13, 2015 at 2:30 pm

      • Of course, I’m always amazing; )


        May 13, 2015 at 2:31 pm

      • Woah hoh woah! Hold up! You’re SOMETIMES amazing Kevo. If you were always amazing, then you wouldnt be amazing ;)

        Liked by 1 person

        May 13, 2015 at 5:41 pm

      • Very true! Now it’s your turn to be amazing!


        May 13, 2015 at 5:59 pm

      • That I am ;)

        Liked by 1 person

        May 13, 2015 at 6:03 pm

  2. I’m still enjoying Hearthstone, but then again I have been playing it daily since launch. If I were new to the game, or returning to it after a long absence I, I would struggle to compete without spending cash.


    May 13, 2015 at 1:12 pm

    • Thats exactly the problem. Even in MTG, you can win with a newbies deck. Hearthstone, for this fact, is unbalanced sadly.

      It’s still fun though :)

      Liked by 1 person

      May 13, 2015 at 2:28 pm

  3. hummm i think a game should always let new players have a chance of winning, too – ok, it is nice when long time players have something as ‘reward’, too but still in a game we are looking for a challenge, right?… difficult topic i guess and probably everyone has a tad bit different opinion XD

    Liked by 1 person

    May 13, 2015 at 11:22 pm

    • Absolutely, but that’s what is so exciting about card games. Sure, they look like something that children will play during their lunch time periods to pass time, but ultimately a good card game can be incredibly stimulating and rewarding.

      The amount of friendships I’ve gained over card games is staggering, so it somewhat annoys me that one of the top games does have such an imbalanced system. With this said, however, as someone pointed out to me: Hearthstone is basically a RNG (Random Number Generator) of a game… So you need to do whatever you can to stack the decks in your favour.

      Still, if you’ve not got the cards, you will not be surviving against anyone with epics, bosses or legendaries. It’s a sad fact with this game! Though there is something hilariously satisfying about using Hex (Turn target into a 0/2 frog with taunt) on Deathwing!

      Liked by 1 person

      May 13, 2015 at 11:27 pm

Drop us a line

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.