Geek Proud, GeekOut.

Sin City vs. The Spirit

I still don’t know what to call this series about films. I’m carrying on with it anyway. Here’s a sore point for me…

Why did Sin City get a sequel?

Actually I suppose my bigger question here is: what was Sin City‘s appeal? A decent cast of characters, a very slick but not entirely original cinematography style, and the direction wasn’t so bad all told, but all together it’s a very medium film. It did very well at the box office for 18 rated film, and has enjoyed success enough since 2005 to warrant a sequel nine years later.*

The story-lines kind of clunked together. They built up an interesting world but they never truly blend, and the script, while full of interesting metaphors and so on gets tired and monotonous all too quickly. With very few exceptions the characters are predictable, and putting on a permanent scowl is the acting equivalent of role-playing the lone-wolf cliché. Don’t get me wrong, I see the appeal, but I also see too many flaws and cut-corners to really enjoy what I’m watching.

A Dame To Kill For was far worse. Gone was the any trace of originality, the colour palette visuals had – by 2014 – been done to death, another all-star cast of wasted potential, not even Josh Brolin seemed to enjoy his own performance. Continuity was officially gone, and the horrible cameos by Mickey Rourke (reprising the role of Marv) only finished the bad job.

All in all, these two left me with a sour taste, especially because I waited to watch Sin City until I was no longer sick to death of being told to watch Sin City. I did the same with 300, and the less said about Watchmen, Lord of the Rings… y’know what, that’s another list altogether, I’ll leave that be for now. To coin a phrase, “Meh”. If this is what the mainstream has to offer you can keep it, I’m going back to my blu-ray collection, wake me up for the next Marvel instalment.

Why did everyone hate The Spirit?

Actually I do understand why some people would dislike it. The Spirit was released in 2008, three years after sin city, so it will have the strong appearance of a copy-cat film. But I am utterly lost as to why the highest rated review on IMDB describes a practically empty screening that ended up far emptier by the end of the film. There is a lot to love:

The cast is spectacular, but it sadly absorbed a lot of the budget, sets are minimal, and a lot of the effects are clearly stripped down, but not unwatchably so. The script apparently put a lot of people off, but it’s a difficult task to blend cheesy and originality, very early in the film, Samuel L. Jackson hits Gabriel Macht over the head with a toilet, then when Gabriel doesn’t laugh, he says “What? Toilets are always funny!” which is a moment that sets the tone of weirdly offbeat comedic action.

The characters are over the top from the excessive personalities to the bad-pun names, like Sand Saref the good-girl turned bad, or Plaster of Paris, the lunatic assassin belly-dancer. The whole thing is crowned by a glorious villains-monologue by Samuel L. Jackson, dressed as a nazi, backed up by his stone-faced cohort Scarlett Johansson. It wasn’t bad taste by this point, because the film has already set a president for clever/stupid. A black nazi suddenly becomes a rational step.


I’m not trying to defend The Spirit as a good film, but it has one major point in it’s favour. While watching Sin City, at no point do I feel as though the cast enjoyed making either films, but The Spirit almost feels like an actors playground. Every performance is a giggle, at no point is any part taken seriously because no part is serious. To compare the two seems almost unfair as they are so very divorced from one another except in colour style.


But they cannot help but be compared, two neo-noir films based on graphic novels. Even the art direction is the same when it comes to pacing, camera angles, environments. It should be hard not to discuss one without the other, but somehow The Spirit gets forgotten, and that seems unjust.

Please, somebody explain it to me. What has The Spirit done to be so slammed in the court of public opinion when worse films get accolades laid upon them. Give me your opinions in the comments below!


*Let it be known that the nine year gap between Sin City 1 and 2 makes the possibility of a Dredd Sequel with Karl Urban seem less dead in the water, and more sleeping under the ice. This makes me very hopeful.



6 responses

  1. Oh if only we could get a Dredd sequel with Karl Urban, I can’t quite give up hoping either.

    Interesting post about Sin City. I remember quite enjoying the first one but I think a lot of its appeal was just the visuals which did feel quite fresh at the time. Not so now, I still haven’t seen the sequel and haven’t really any desire to.


    February 19, 2015 at 10:49 pm

    • It’s my opinion against everyone else’s of course, I’ve grown accustomed to that role in life, I just liked the Spirit more.

      My favourite part about the Dredd 2 campaign is that Karl Urban is leading the charge.


      February 20, 2015 at 12:52 am

  2. I liked the first two stories of Sin City, but have not seen the sequel. I have stayed away from The Spirit due to the negative reviews.


    February 20, 2015 at 10:11 am

    • I never let a bad review turn me away, just occasionally you come up with a real underloved jewel. I’ll see if I can find some more for you :)


      February 20, 2015 at 2:24 pm

  3. The Spirit was flawed but fun and stylish. I’m in two minds about a Dredd 2, I’d like to see it but in reality the first one needed to do much better so that a sequel would be viable but with a bigger budget to really open up the world of Dredd.


    February 23, 2015 at 8:38 am

  4. Pingback: Treasure Planet vs. Titan AE | GeekOut South-West

Drop us a line

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.